Purina Pro Plan Indoor Salmon & Rice Review: Vet-Recommended for a Reason?

Quick verdict: Purina Pro Plan Indoor is one of the most vet-recommended indoor cat foods for good reason. After 30 days of testing, it delivered excellent palatability, visibly improved coat quality, and the live probiotics genuinely seem to support digestive regularity. It contains corn gluten meal and some formulations include artificial colors, which ingredient-conscious owners may not love, but the nutritional profile is strong, the feeding trial substantiation is meaningful, and the price sits comfortably in the mid-premium range. We rate it 4.5 out of 5.

Meowing Goods is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more

Why We Tested Purina Pro Plan Indoor

The pet food market is full of bold claims and beautiful packaging. Marketing budgets are enormous, and it can be genuinely difficult for a cat owner to separate products that are well-formulated and well-tested from products that simply have good branding. Purina Pro Plan occupies an interesting position in this landscape: it is one of the three brands most commonly recommended by veterinary professionals (alongside Royal Canin and Hill’s Science Diet), yet it often receives criticism from the ingredient-focused community for using corn gluten meal and poultry by-products.

We wanted to test it without bias in either direction. Is vet recommendation alone enough to justify the price? Does the probiotic supplementation make a measurable difference? How does it stack up against the ingredient-forward brands like Blue Buffalo Tastefuls that market directly to owners who read ingredient lists?

Our testing panel included eight adult indoor cats ranging from 7 to 14 pounds, representing a mix of breeds and temperaments. We transitioned each cat gradually over 10 days and monitored palatability, stool quality, coat condition, energy levels, and body weight over the full 30-day trial period. Prior to the test, cats were eating a variety of brands including Blue Buffalo, Iams, and Hill’s Science Diet, giving us a diverse baseline.

Live Probiotics and Digestive Health

The signature feature of Purina Pro Plan’s current formula line is the inclusion of guaranteed live probiotics — specifically Lactobacillus acidophilus. This is not a trivial marketing addition. Delivering live probiotic cultures in dry kibble is technically challenging because the bacteria must survive the high-temperature manufacturing process, shelf storage, and passage through stomach acid to reach the intestines where they provide benefit.

Purina addresses this with a proprietary coating process applied after cooking that protects the probiotic cultures. The guaranteed analysis on the bag includes a minimum viable colony count, meaning Purina is committing to a specific level of live cultures at the time of feeding — not just at the time of manufacturing. This is a higher standard than many competitor products that list probiotics in their ingredients without guaranteeing viability.

In practical terms, we observed measurable improvements in stool quality across our test panel. Among the six cats that transitioned smoothly, four showed firmer, more consistent stools by the end of the first week. Two cats that had chronic soft stool on their previous diets showed the most dramatic improvement. One cat’s owner described the change as “the best litter box experience we’ve had in two years.”

The Cornell Feline Health Center notes that digestive health is one of the most important factors in a cat’s overall wellbeing, and probiotics are an increasingly supported tool for maintaining a healthy gut microbiome. While probiotics are not a substitute for veterinary treatment of diagnosed GI conditions, they can support baseline digestive function in healthy cats.

Ingredient Quality and Nutritional Profile

Let us address the ingredient list directly, because this is where Purina Pro Plan generates the most debate.

What is genuinely good: Chicken is the first ingredient. Chicken by-product meal is second — and before you react negatively to “by-products,” it is worth understanding what this actually means. Poultry by-product meal includes organ meats (liver, heart, gizzard), which are nutritionally dense and are the parts of the animal that cats would eat first in a natural hunting scenario. Board-certified veterinary nutritionists consistently point out that by-products are not “junk” — they are often more nutrient-dense than skeletal muscle meat. The formula also includes rice, which is gentle on digestion, and fish meal, which provides omega-3 fatty acids.

What gives us pause: Corn gluten meal is a plant-based protein concentrate that contributes to the total protein percentage but does not provide the same complete amino acid profile as animal protein. While it is safe and digestible, its presence means the 38% crude protein on the guaranteed analysis is not all from animal sources. Some formulations also include artificial colors — FD&C Red No. 40, Yellow No. 5, Blue No. 2 — that serve no nutritional purpose and exist solely to make the kibble more visually appealing to humans. Cats are dichromats and do not perceive these colors the way we do. These additives are approved by the FDA as safe for consumption, but we would prefer to see them removed.

The guaranteed analysis is strong:

The AAFCO substantiation method is a critical differentiator. Pro Plan Indoor is substantiated through feeding trials, meaning real cats ate this food as their sole diet for a defined period under veterinary supervision, and their health markers were monitored throughout. Many competing brands rely solely on formulation analysis, which confirms the food meets minimum nutrient profiles on paper but does not verify real-world performance. This distinction matters, and it is one of the primary reasons veterinarians tend to recommend brands that conduct feeding trials.

Palatability and Feeding Experience

Seven of our eight test cats accepted Pro Plan Indoor without hesitation during the transition period. The one holdout, a notoriously picky Russian Blue, needed an extra-long 14-day transition with higher ratios of her previous food before fully accepting the switch. This is a strong acceptance rate — higher than the six-of-eight we saw with Blue Buffalo Tastefuls Indoor.

The kibble is a mix of brown, tan, and reddish pieces (the color variation comes from the artificial colors in some batches and the LifeSource-style nutrient blend). The pieces are small and round, which most cats handled easily. However, the small size means cats who tend to gulp their food can eat very quickly. If your cat is a fast eater, pairing this food with a puzzle feeder like the Catit Digger can slow them down and add enrichment.

We did not observe any cats picking around specific kibble pieces, which can be an issue with foods that include visually distinct nutrient nuggets. The flavor was uniformly accepted, suggesting the palatability coating is well-distributed across all pieces.

Hairball and Indoor Cat Performance

Pro Plan Indoor includes a natural fiber blend designed to move ingested hair through the digestive tract rather than allowing it to accumulate into hairballs. The fiber content (6.5% maximum) is slightly lower than Blue Buffalo Tastefuls Indoor (7%), but in our testing, the hairball reduction performance was comparable.

Among our three long-haired test cats, two showed a meaningful reduction in hairball frequency over the 30-day period. One went from approximately three hairballs per week to one, and another went from two per week to roughly one every 10 days. The third long-haired cat showed no change, but that cat also tolerates regular deshedding with a FURminator, which is the more impactful intervention for hairball prevention.

For the indoor-specific weight management claim, the calorie density of 454 kcal/cup is actually moderate-to-high for a food marketed to less active indoor cats. It is critical to follow the feeding guidelines on the bag and measure portions accurately. We recommend using a kitchen scale or designated measuring cup rather than eyeballing portions, as overfeeding calorie-dense food is one of the most common causes of weight gain in indoor cats.

Value Assessment

Purina Pro Plan Indoor is priced in the mid-premium range, sitting between budget brands and ultra-premium options:

• Budget brands (Meow Mix, Friskies, Kit & Kaboodle): $0.25-0.40/day
• Purina Pro Plan Indoor (this product): $0.55-0.70/day
• Blue Buffalo Tastefuls Indoor: $0.60-0.75/day
• Ultra-premium brands (Orijen, Instinct, Tiki Cat): $1.20-2.00/day

The value proposition is strong. You get feeding trial substantiation, live probiotics, a high protein content, and one of the most researched formulations on the market — all at a price that is competitive with or below ingredient-focused brands that rely on formulation analysis only. The wide retail availability also means you can find it at virtually any grocery store, pet store, or online retailer, reducing the risk of running out and needing to make an abrupt diet switch.

Compared to the other vet-recommended brands, Pro Plan is generally less expensive than Royal Canin and competitively priced with Hill’s Science Diet, making it the value leader in the vet-recommended category.

Comparison Table: Pro Plan Indoor vs. Blue Buffalo Tastefuls vs. Hill’s Indoor

Who It Is For

Buy Purina Pro Plan Indoor if:

• You trust your veterinarian’s recommendation and want a food with feeding trial substantiation
• Digestive health is a priority and you want guaranteed live probiotics in your cat’s daily diet
• Your indoor cat needs hairball support and moderate calorie control
• You want a widely available brand that you can find at any store in a pinch
• High protein content matters — 38% is well above AAFCO minimums
• You are stepping up from a budget brand and want a meaningful quality improvement without ultra-premium pricing
• Your cat has been eating another Pro Plan formula and you want to switch to the indoor-specific version

Skip Purina Pro Plan Indoor if:

• You are committed to an ingredient list with no corn, by-products, or artificial additives
• Your cat has a diagnosed chicken or corn allergy
• You want the lowest calorie density for weight management (Hill’s or Blue Buffalo may be better fits)
• You exclusively feed wet food
• You prefer a grain-free formula (though note that grain-free diets have been linked to potential heart issues by the FDA)

For a comprehensive guide to evaluating cat food quality, see our How to Choose Cat Food guide. If you are considering other indoor cat food options, our Blue Buffalo Tastefuls Indoor review provides a detailed breakdown of the leading ingredient-focused alternative.

Final Verdict

Purina Pro Plan Indoor earns a 4.5 out of 5 from Meowing Goods. It is a well-formulated, well-tested food that delivers on its core promises: high protein, live probiotics for digestive health, hairball control for indoor cats, and the backing of extensive feeding trial research. The inclusion of corn gluten meal and artificial colors in some batches keeps it from a perfect score, but the nutritional profile, digestive benefits, and value proposition are genuinely strong.

This is a food that veterinarians recommend for good reasons — not because of marketing relationships, but because it meets the standards that veterinary nutritionists use to evaluate quality: named animal protein sources, feeding trial substantiation, guaranteed probiotic viability, and consistent manufacturing quality. If you want a food you can feel confident about from a nutrition science perspective, Pro Plan Indoor delivers.

Check Price on Amazon

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Purina Pro Plan Indoor actually recommended by veterinarians?

Yes, Purina Pro Plan is one of the most commonly recommended brands among veterinary professionals. It is frequently recommended alongside Royal Canin and Hill’s Science Diet. The distinction matters because Pro Plan formulas are substantiated through AAFCO feeding trials — actual controlled feeding studies with real cats over defined periods — rather than relying solely on nutritional formulation analysis. This means the food has been proven to sustain adult cats as a sole diet in real-world conditions. Additionally, Purina employs a large team of veterinary nutritionists and board-certified specialists, and the brand funds extensive peer-reviewed research.

Does Purina Pro Plan contain corn gluten meal, and is that a problem?

Yes, corn gluten meal is listed among the ingredients. Corn gluten meal is a concentrated plant protein that is highly digestible in cats and provides essential amino acids, though not the complete amino acid profile that animal proteins provide. The controversy around corn gluten meal is largely driven by marketing from grain-free brands rather than veterinary science. Board-certified veterinary nutritionists generally agree that corn and corn-derived ingredients are safe, digestible, and nutritionally useful in cat food when used alongside adequate animal protein sources. If your cat has a diagnosed corn allergy — which is rare — this formula would not be appropriate. Otherwise, the presence of corn gluten meal is not a meaningful nutritional concern.

What probiotics are in Purina Pro Plan Indoor?

Pro Plan Indoor contains a guaranteed amount of live Lactobacillus acidophilus, a probiotic strain that has been studied for its ability to support digestive health in companion animals. The probiotics are added after the cooking process using a proprietary coating technology that protects the live cultures from heat degradation and stomach acid, allowing them to reach the intestinal tract alive. Pro Plan’s guaranteed analysis includes a minimum viable count per serving, which is a more reliable standard than simply listing probiotics on the ingredient panel.

How does Purina Pro Plan Indoor compare to Blue Buffalo Tastefuls Indoor?

Both are solid mid-premium indoor cat foods, but they take different approaches. Pro Plan Indoor has a higher protein content (38% vs 32%), is backed by feeding trials rather than formulation alone, and contains live probiotics. Blue Buffalo Tastefuls Indoor uses deboned chicken as its first ingredient, excludes corn, wheat, and soy, and does not use poultry by-products. Pro Plan is more widely available and typically costs less per pound. If probiotics, feeding trial substantiation, and vet recommendations matter most, choose Pro Plan. If you prioritize a no-by-product, no-corn ingredient list, Blue Buffalo is the better fit. See our Blue Buffalo Tastefuls Indoor review for a detailed breakdown.

Sources

1. AAFCO Pet Food Labeling Guide
2. Cornell Feline Health Center — Feeding Your Cat
3. AVMA — Selecting Pet Food